Will children’s books become obsolete?

By heather at 10:57 pm on Thursday, February 11, 2010

I stumbled across this interesting discussion on Amazon.com, where someone asks “Is there a chance that the physical books will become useless use because of Kindle edition digital books?

I’ve wondered the same thing, whether children’s picture books will become obsolete in the new wave of digital book readers. I’m all for novels, newspapers, and magazine content being digitized, and think it is an excellent way to reduce paper waste. (I also think it would be awesome reading in bed at night, too, as the book acts as its own night light :) I do love paper books, but think that paper novels will soon become collectors items (or print-on-demand) for those that love that smell & feel of old paper, as the digital copies are just so practical and sustainable.

But for children’s books I think digitizing them to read on a screen is a horrible idea!

Being a children’s book illustrator I’m just a little biased… I love picture books, and think there’s something wonderfully tactile about turning the pages with anticipation of what’s on the next page. I tend to cringe at books with added bells & whistles like electronic noise and lights, as I feel there is so much creativity to be enjoyed in the 2D illustrations, subtle textures, and die cuts. Not to mention where will the line be drawn in the future between static digitzed illustrations and animated books? It would be SO tempting for publishers to animate parts of children’s books, and essentially turn digital books into tv.

Being a mum, I value reading and want to pass that onto my daughter. Paper books are also wonderful for helping a child develop their coordination… I’ve enjoyed watching my toddler grow from learning to turn the chunky pages of a board book to now carefully turning pages of regular picture books. The enjoyment I see her have in finding the ladybugs I’ve hidden in the illustrations, to even reciting bits of the stories we’ve read together is hard to imagine on a small digital screen. Heh, I can clearly imagine the blank stare she would have staring at a digital book… it’s the same stare she gets when the tv is on! Nowadays I think we parents rely a lot on electronics to entertain our kids, and I would love books for children to remain tactile.

Filed under: inspiration, childrens books, business of illustration

6 Comments »

1
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by jen

February 12, 2010 @ 10:00 am

I could not agree with you more! Books are a very important part of childhood. I’m with you! :)

2
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Ann-Mi

February 12, 2010 @ 11:59 pm

I also agree. Plus, I actually find it difficult to read things on the screen. If there is something I want to read properly, I have to print it out. I’ve not experienced a Kindle thingy but nothing can possibly compare to actually turning the pages of a book.
A lot of books also have cool things, like pages to touch, scratch and sniff, holes in them where you can see the next page, etc. I can’t imagine electronic books replacing this for a long time.

3
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Dena

February 14, 2010 @ 8:19 pm

I agree with you 100%! My two year old LOVES to read picture books for hours on end. As it is, she loves to be read to, and she loves to “read” to herself - babbling and singing as she turns the pages. She becomes engrossed in each book as she turns the pages and looks at the pictures. If children’s books became digitized, she would lose the wonderful experience and education she is getting from reading.

4
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by Nayan

February 22, 2010 @ 11:08 pm

Dear Heather

Will paper greeting cards also become obsolete…just want to know your thoughts as you are in the business for so long and have done such great work…
I am just starting to delve into paper greeting and am pretty confused and tensed..hahaha…please comment…

5
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by heather

February 24, 2010 @ 8:27 pm

Hi Nayan,
Thanks for your question on my blog re whether I think greeting cards will become obsolete… you know, I don’t think they will go completely, but the industry is certainly slowing down quite a bit! There’s been quite a transition from paper cards to more complex e-cards, so think there will have to be some sort of crossover for illustrators between the two varieties if we want to keep illustrating seasonal & pretty images!

Cheers,
Heather Castles

6
Get your own gravatar for comments by visiting gravatar.com

Comment by priyanka

March 17, 2010 @ 11:59 am

Hello,

Enjoyed reading your post - and got reminded of my own pleasure in turning pages of big colourfully illustrated story books. As a kid, I got a huge kick out of a book I received as a prize in school - in this one if you turned the page, the cardboard illustrations (folded) would pop up and stand upright, like paper cutouts! I would like to believe that neither paper novels or books for children are in any danger of becoming obsolete - the situation is very different from on-demand greeting cards - as people buy books to savour and read:-) plus e-books are very, very difficult to read, sustainedly.

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a comment